Posted by: Philip Carr-Gomm | November 9, 2007

George Monbiot for Prime Minister

Richard’s book Endangered Species that I mentioned yesterday is all about the endangered species of English country folk, but after meeting with him I went on to hear George Monbiot, and three other speakers (one from Greenpeace, one from The Campaign Against Climate Change and one from the Heathrow Climate Camp) talk about the wider endangered species – the human being.

Monbiot should be Prime Minister. The situation is unbelievably gloomy and yet he is able to offer a lifeline of hope while still being sober and realistic. As a masterful orator he is completely conversant with his subject, and is able to talk about such a difficult situation with humanity and humour.

It’s best to go the horse’s mouth to hear what he has to say. Have a look at his website and at a project he refers to: Zero Carbon Britain. The latest research shows that only zero carbon emissions can now avert climate catastrophe. Although this seems impossible to achieve, Monbiot believes it can be done. It would apparently not be expensive to create an array of solar panels across the Sahara and a field of windmills in the North Sea that would feed into the European grid and give enough zero-carbon electricity to power all of Europe. But is there enough political will to achieve this? And then there’s the rest of the world…

But as he finished by saying: “If not now, when? If not here, where? If not us, then who?”

To give you a feel for the power of his ideas, here’s an excerpt from his site. He’s one of those people who dares to say what many of us only dare to think…

Bring on the Recession

How else will the destructive effects of growth be stopped?

By George Monbiot. Published in the Guardian 9th October 2007

If you are of a sensitive disposition, I advise you to turn the page now. I am about to break the last of the universal taboos. I hope that the recession now being forecast by some economists materialises.

I recognise that recession causes hardship. Like everyone I am aware that it would cause some people to lose their jobs and homes. I do not dismiss these impacts or the harm they inflict, though I would argue that they are the avoidable results of an economy designed to maximise growth rather than welfare. What I would like you to recognise is something much less discussed: that, beyond a certain point, hardship is also caused by economic growth.

On Sunday I visited the only UN biosphere reserve in Wales: the Dyfi estuary. As is usual at weekends, several hundred people had come to enjoy its beauty and tranquillity and, as is usual, two or three people on jet skis were spoiling it for everyone else. Most economists will tell us that human welfare is best served by multiplying the number of jet skis. If there are two in the estuary today, there should be four there by this time next year and eight the year after. Because the estuary’s beauty and tranquillity don’t figure in the national accounts (no one pays to watch the sunset) and because the sale and use of jet skis does, this is deemed an improvement in human welfare….

George Monbiot


Responses

  1. You have taken leave of your senses. Monbiot is economically and scientifically hopeless.

  2. Explain Jonathan!

  3. Monbiot is an environmental hysteric. He is profoundly unscientific and prejudicially selective in the information he presents. He urges policies that would condemn millions to poverty. When Monbiot asserts something is clear you can be pretty certain it isn ‘t.

  4. Just thinking: An interesting video from TED.com about climate change at http://www.ted.com/index.php/talks/view/id/192
    (note there are a number of other very interesting videos on the http://www.ted.com site)

    and also for you living in the UK a carbon calculator:
    http://www.carbontrust.co.uk/solutions/CarbonFootprinting/FootprintCalculators

    This later doesn’t really work in NZ due – in main to the different electricity production systems here in NZ – but air travel still rates highest in caarbon contribution

  5. I’ve always found Monbiot to be interesting and a worthy spokesman for the environmental movement. His battle with David Bellamy is of course rather extraordinary. I remember watching the groundbreaking ‘Bellamy on Botany’ in the 70s and being transfixed by his wonderfully fresh approach. To see the bearded botanist take such an extraordinary stance re global warming is more than a little dispiriting.

  6. Monbiot is a puppet of the nuclear who plagiarizes good people like Dr Dick Van Steenis RIP and attacks those environmentalists who have had the misfortune of supporting him.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: